Brendan’s £15m Meal – Was Joe Allen an unnecessary ingredient?


David Stanyon explains how Brendan Rodgers‘ signing of Joe Allen this summer might have been a case of an ingredient that wasn’t required, given the resources already available.

There’s something which just wasn’t sitting too well with me, & with my every effort I really did try to support the concept of it I just couldn’t see the application.

I could be talking about Jamie’s 15 minuet meals, where Jamie Oliver takes undercooked, still “mooing” filleted beef, adds some modern micro salad leaves dripping in Balsamic Vinegar & then serves it up on a sanded floor board salvaged from the barn on Jimmy’s Farm, the 3 components don’t quite go but he’s the Chef right? What’s next serving meals on a paving slab from his driveway?

That wasn’t quite my quandary; it’s not quite the component mismatch that wasn’t sitting right & after the recent 3 Liverpool performances away to Manchester United, Arsenal & Man City its became both evident & confusing.


When Brendan Rodgers became Liverpool manager all the buzz words from last season were replaced with new hope filled words; transition was replaced with philosophy; pass and move became Tiki Taka; and who could forget “death by football”.

The summer transfer window was nothing short of amateurish, fortunately, the January signings of Daniel Sturridge and Coutinho has give validation Tom Werner & John Henry’s words of “putting it right” and have in some way repaired the August debacle.

The shortage of transfer funds in the summer raised eyebrows, but the fresh start of a new manager put those financial questions on the backburner as he had a squad far better than that he worked with in his previous appointments.

The departures of Craig Bellamy, Dirk Kuyt and Maxi Rodriguez were all surprising given their football abilities to play in a 4-3-3 fluid system but not so surprising giving the “wages” that could be “saved”. All three seem to have been heading out before Rodgers took over.

This left Luis Suarez and new boy Fabio Borini as the only forwards at the club. The midfield, on the other hand, had an abundance of talent that Rodgers could have only dreamed about at other clubs; Gerrard, Lucas, Henderson, Aquilani, Shelvey, Adam, and wee Jay Spearing.

In 2011/12 only Barcelona from the top 5 leagues in Europe had more proportion of play in the final third than Liverpool, with our top League scorers Suarez 11, Bellamy 6, Gerrard 5, Carroll 4, Maxi 4 while Kuyt & Adam chipped in with 2 a piece.

From that list above only Suarez and Gerrard were able to continue into 2012/13, it’s conclusive we had the play, we had the shots (4th best in the league), we just didn’t have the ability to put the ball in the back of the net, creating the attack wasn’t the issue, it was finishing the attack.

The midfield emptied of Aquilani, Adam and Spearing as loan signing Nuri Sahin and £15m Joe Allen arrived with excitement. The “Welsh Xavi” taking up 50% of a below par transfer budget in an area that was not key to strengthen given the previous season’s lack of goals and player departures from an attacking point of view.

By all attempts Clint Dempsey didn’t fit a “profile” and Daniel Sturridge was looked at as a loan possibility only.

Given all of the above its clear that with Rodgers’ ideas of a passing midfield, the evident need for goals and the shortage of budget, was it really wise to spend £15m (50% of our budget) on Joe Allen and not pursue Daniel Sturridge in the summer more seriously, or Demba Ba perhaps?

Yes hindsight is a wonderful thing.

Joe Allen

Joe Allen started his career at LFC well, ball retention and simplistic distribution being the main components to his game.

Lucas picked up an injury and Allen filled that void. Once Lucas returned Joe’s performances fell slightly but this was due to being held back in the defensive cover role while Lucas recovered. Rodgers assured us, now Lucas was back we would see a better Allen pushed higher up the pitch.

Allen was dipping, Gerrard looked lost at times trying to find his place or “zones” in this new 3-man system and Henderson and Sahin’s appearances were limited. Which worries me, here you have what Rodgers dubbed the “Welsh Xavi”, the England and England U21 captains, Turkish International Sahin and a much-improved Shelvey to select in a midfield 3, and it looked a mess. In an area that is key to the ideals in which Rodgers is schooled in. He should have the way his midfield should play nailed, no excuse.

If a manager claims to be bringing a solid defensive play to a side, you’d expect him to be clued up on defence, if a manager is claiming to want to play with out & out wingers you would expect him to know how to make wing play work, so the midfield is pivotal to the managers ideal that people hang onto, so why couldn’t he get it right? He works with the players, he trains them and he sees their pros and cons.

Sure we can all fire stats about, who’s passing where and how much % of passing Joe Allen has, but the fact remains that the midfield blend wasn’t right and it was apparent to me early on that perhaps Brendan was trying to accommodate his “go-to man” Allen, but maybe at a bigger expense.

Henderson’s confidence shattered? Jonjo’s appearances limited? Gerrard looking lost? And Nuri Sahin is now back in Germany with Jurgen Klopp questioning Rodgers use of him. A simple situation being made more complex by the need to play Allen.

It appears like the preference was given to tame the Gerrard beast and free up Allen to move forward, but it renders the skippers natural instinct to drive forward useless. Allen then wanders around looking lost, Gerrard is ineffective and Lucas is being bypassed through wide-play.

Therein lies the Jamie Oliver metaphor at the start of this, it’s been a mess at times, a few ingredients in the hands of an expert of these ingredients and it’s just at times been slapped on a board and hoped it tastes right.

Again why can’t a student of midfield passing not see his midfielder’s attributes? Is it again to accommodate Joe Allen? Are you telling me Sahin, Gerrard, Lucas, Henderson or Shelvey can’t pass simplistically and retain the ball between them? Of course they can.

I suggested a few months ago that Rodgers metal as a manager will be evident if he leaves Allen collecting splinters in his arse on the bench. Recently, to Rodgers credit, he has benched his guy and looked at more what fits better together, what ingredients go best with each other.

Was Allen a “standard” buy from his former manager? More than likely, but was that a chunk of the budget that could have been used on a Sturridge given the obvious lack of striker options. Perhaps Rodgers should have given the squad he had more of a chance, the revival of Jordan Henderson is proof of that, Downing too maybe?


If you look at the graphic, Joe Allen so far this season has contributed to 2 areas better than that of Adam and Spearing from last season; one is the passing, the other mainly in losing. The stats show he has contributed nothing in an attacking sense demonstrating that his passing is “too safe”.

No league goals so far, not even a single shot on target or an assist.

I’m not saying Allen is a poor signing, or a bad player he just doesn’t seem to fit right into our midfield at the moment. Charlie Adam looked a class act in the Blackpool midfield but alongside Gerrard and co he looked lost, gave the ball away and committed needless fouls. The same has happened with Allen, it’s not a attack on Joe its a observation that’s apparent and one which has made Rodgers seem foolish early on – after all this is the area you would expect Rodgers to nail, the midfield.

“If’s” and hindsight are brilliant, but I feel that Rodgers would have been best suited addressing the area that needed it and not that in which he had an abundance of talent already.


The recent performances at Arsenal and Man City have shown that the blend of the midfield 3 is right at the moment and long may it be given time to develop, even if it means that Rodgers’ man is on the bench. Allen needs to find himself and know what he is as a player, just as Lucas did a few years ago.

Sturridge’s impact at the top end of the pitch is credit to playing with a World class player like Suarez and feeding off that quality to open his box of talent up and it’s there for all to see. Allen on the other hand couldn’t open himself up when playing with Gerrard, whereas Henderson has fed off Gerrard and exposed his attributes to the skippers talent and its benefiting Jordan right now. The blend is right and it’s working.

A lesson I hope Rodgers has learned; forget the overcomplicating of ingredients to what you have, no need to throw it all together and hope it tastes right.

Open some bacon, get a bun and slap on some ketchup, because sometimes the right ingredients just work. Even if it does mean your favourite ingredient isn’t required.

More: , , , ,
Straight talking passionate red from way up north, I started writing about 18 month ago for a few websites & now onboard with TIA. I write what I think & not what will make me popular; my articles are straight talking with a blend of humour & sarcasm at times. Healthy debate welcome. Follow on twitter @davidstan76 or visit my website at

More on This Is Anfield

More LFC news, opinion & videos

Fan Comments

Comments are retrospectively moderated. Some could be subject to delays before publication. They must obey the comment policy. Comments load below.

Please only discuss the article above. General chat can be made on our forums at


  1. FSGsHT have continuously harped on value for money and resale value of players. This is not a new concept, as many small – medium sized clubs use this business model. You spend 10m on 3 players hoping that one can be coveted by the top 6 and sell him back for a profit. Top clubs do it to… for example Wenger has been a master of paying small for big players. However even he has had to dig deep recently to acquire the best talents. While having to swallow the fact that FSGsHT are now slowing trying to make us believe Liverpool are to be managed like Swansea or West Brom, how does the purchase of Allen fit in this all? Granted he is young. And he was brilliant for Swansea. But 15m? Does anyone seriously believe we could get more than 7m if we ever contemplate selling him? Better he may get… but will he ever command a regular place in a top 4 premiership team? Allen was all Brenda’s idea, as much as Carroll was all Kenny’s. The mistake was half as bad, but nevertheless a mistake! I have no doubt at all that, if Brenda had gone in for Sturridge at the beginning of the season, we would not only have been 5m richer, but we would be in a better position up the table and we could have been looking at Ince and another player in January.

    • Why do they let docile people on these sites????You would of called The Great Shankly,Shelia as he started slowly,wind your neck in son…YNWA

      • I guess its the same reason they allow those that are mentally challenged, just like you… its called free speak.

  2. I think you’re being a slightly harsh on Rodgers. When the team started playing at the beginning of the season they stuck closely to the principles Rodgers had in mind, principles that would’ve fit Allen’s style of play well. As the season progressed it became apparent that to accommodate the particular strengths of the squad certain alterations needed to be made to how we played. Unfortunately for Allen, those alterations took the team’s way of playing further away from his natural game, which is why he now appears lost. But we must remember that when Allen was acquired Rodgers intended the side to play using his original model, it was only through the evolution of our system of play that Allen became less relevant. I actually applaud Rodgers for being flexible enough to amend his principles of play for the greater good of the side rather than persisting with a methodology that didn’t maximise the potential of the players.

  3. its something i commented on, while on another Liverpool site. Many of us were angry at the way the summer market was handled. We saw attacking talent heading out the door in the form of kuyt, bellamy, and maxi, in order to trim the wage bill. Over the summer an estimated £20 odd million per annum was cut off the wage bill. As the author mentioned & as many others commented on over the course of last season and beyond, we had plenty of attacking play, created many chances, had many shots on target, but we were profligate in front of goal. Many had a out and out goalscorer as top of their summer wishlist, someone to increase our cutting edge in the final third. Rodgers went for borini, he clearly believes in the player but he is young, the jury is still out and it wasnt likely that he ws going to hone our cutting edge this season at least. Rodgers also moved for dempsey of course & what happened next is what generated such anger. By all accounts the club offered £4 million, fulham asked for an extra £2million to equal that offered by other clubs, LiverpoolLiverpool tried using henderson as a makeweightmakeweight, which he refused, and in the end the owners refused the extra £2 million and rogers missed one of his prime targets. Carroll had already been loaned out & rodgers had stated that he would ‘have to be insane to let carroll leave without being sure of having a replacement’ so it seemed for the sake of £2 million the owners were content to leave rodgers looking foolish, seeming to be publicly undermined, and for the club to enter a new season with just one senior forward of any experience. That is what many of us focussed on, but of course it is true that Rodgers was given just over £30 million to spend, knew the team had created a host of attacking play the previous season, had said goodbye to two of our forwards and an attacking goalscoring midfielder in maxi, and yet he didnt focus these funds on our threadbare forward options. the bulk was spent on allen, an area were we already had a number of talented players vying for the three spots available, especially with the loan of sahin. and borini, the only forward added, bringing us to a total of just 2 senior forwards, one of them a 21yo rookie with plenty still to learn. Im not knocking allen, he could well become a valued player for the club. But it is fair to say that the overwhelming priority during the summer should have been our forward options, and that spending 50% of the budget on a cm should have been something left for a future window, if it was needed. Either way you look at it, it was a serious mistake of entering this season with just 2 senior forwards, one of them a young rookie. If the club fails to finish in a CL place then that mistake will prove costly and there is no doubt the recriminations about the mistakes made in the summer will resurface.

  4. $25 million for Borini and Allan was very misguided. For a team which clearly lacks the financial backing of the top teams, Rodgers should have focused on our initial problem – finding a world class striker.

    Though I’m yet to be convinced by Rodgers’ naive tactics I must say, I am impressed by his faith in Sturridge who, not having played much Premiership football, was certainly something of a gamble. I am also impressed by the fact that he has been playing what can be considered our best team, thereby benching the underwhelming Allan and Borini, and choosing Henderson over Shelvey (who, for me is nowhere near ready to be considered for anything other than minor cup competitions and sub appearances)

  5. Bottom line just another looser at £15 million, question is it is difficult to decide who the biggest looser in this squad as there are so many starting with the great man at the helm .

Leave a Reply

Go to homepage