The Reds won the numbers game in the middle of the park as injuries forced Mauricio Pochettino to name Moussa Sissoko and Dele Alli as a duo, but the quality and diversity were lacking.
Fabinho eventually took Henderson’s place on 77 minutes, with the scores level at 1-1, and went on to make a vital impact, including two aerial duels and one big tackle won.
Carragher, speaking as part of Sky Sports’ coverage of the game, described Fabinho as one of those, and suggested he should start every game between now and May.
“I thought he made a big difference when he came on. [Leaving him out] was a slight surprise,” he explained.
“It could be any of three [that he replaced], it’s not a single person you point at.
“It’s just that Liverpool’s starting midfield are very similar players, you know exactly what you’re going to get.
“[When Fabinho came on] his passing and how he wins the ball back quickly [were important].
“I think it’s something we’ll see between now and the end of the season.”
It’s certainly a convincing argument, as while there is stability in the conservative trio of Henderson, Milner and Wijnaldum, there’s a clear lack of impetus.
Starting Fabinho provides both a rock-solid spine and a forward-thinking midfield outlet, whether that be in a 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 system.
The 25-year-old allows that versatility, as the setup shifted shortly before his introduction, and this will be crucial as six very different challenges await.
Klopp can be forgiven for naming Fabinho on the bench on Sunday, following his relatively late return from Brazil duty.
But as Carragher argued, he should now return to being one of the first names on the teamsheet.