The use of VAR in the Premier League leaves a lot to be desired, and those within the game are becoming increasingly impatient with the technology.
While the biggest controversy surrounding VAR is its implementation for marginal offside calls, Saturday brought two decisions that highlight other areas of concern.
In Liverpool’s 1-1 draw with Newcastle, Callum Wilson was denied an equaliser after the ball was adjudged to have struck his arm – despite it being clearly accidental and unavoidable.
RED CARD! ?
Fabian Balbuena is sent off by referee Chris Kavanagh after he caught Ben Chilwell with his follow through. What do you make of the decision?
VAR instructed referee Chris Kavanagh to rewatch the incident on the pitchside monitor, and Balbuena was subsequently sent off for ‘serious foul play’ despite there blatantly being none whatsoever.
“For me the big thing is it’s a really rank, rotten decision and it shouldn’t be given.”
Moyes, of course, could be accused of bias, but the call was roundly criticised from those outside of West Ham, too, including ex-players, commentators and journalists:
Balbuena sent off at West Ham after referee consults replays. I don't get this one. Balbuena clears the ball and his follow through means his foot connects with Chilwell's calf. Effectively been sent off for kicking the ball. Which is a new one, even this season.
— Oliver Holt (@OllieHolt22) April 24, 2021
Here I go again. If that’s a red then ‘the game has gone’ Oh my? it’s beyond a joke. Where is Balbuena suppose to put his leg? In his pocket? Levitate? Somebody please tell me
— Lee Dixon ? (@LeeDixon2) April 24, 2021
Red card !!!!!!!! ???? Is there anybody at that bus who understand football!???
Balbuena, West Ham sent off
— Jan Aage Fjortoft ???? ?? (@JanAageFjortoft) April 24, 2021
More utter nonsense from VAR at West Ham. Ludicrous red card for Balbuena.
— Ian Darke (@IanDarke) April 24, 2021
I’ve seen some bad refereeing decisions this season but that Balbuena red card was quite something #WHUCHE
— Alan Smith (@9smudge) April 24, 2021
Rio Ferdinand went as far as to insist: “VAR needs to be put in the bin now.”
“We’ve tried it and it’s shit. Get rid,” he wrote on Twitter. “It’s slowing the game down and sucking the emotion out of the game.”
Speaking in his post-match press conference, Jurgen Klopp described the decision to overturn Wilson’s goal as “the first time we were lucky with VAR,” lamenting that Liverpool “didn’t even take that present.”
“The captains are willing to put rivalries aside and speak to one another, something that I do not think would have happened before last year,” Mee wrote in the Guardian.
“We like to think we have made a positive impact with this and our money-raising for the NHS, and hopefully we can continue to do so on a wide range of topics for the better of the game and society.”
There are certainly bigger issues to tackle, including a stand against racism and online abuse, but perhaps the players should be consulted on the use of VAR in the future, too.